Wednesday, May 25, 2022

Debunking the Myth of Modernist Development: An Opportune Moment to Walk on the Gandhian Path

Whenever you are in a doubt, or when the self becomes too much with you, apply the following test. Recall the face of the poorest and the weakest man whom you may have seen, and ask yourself, if the step you contemplate is going to be of any use to him. Will he gain anything by it? Will it restore him to a control over his own life and destiny? In other words, will it lead to Swaraj for the hungry and spiritually starving millions?  
                                                                                                    – M.K. Gandhi, 1948

The Crisis

The contemporary model of development in India has been seen as a critical force in the transformation of the society. It is this framework of the modernist development agenda that has been endowed with the possibility of giving a new social character to the Indian society. It is in this context that Immanuel Kant’s reference to modernity as a process of social awakening, as a transition from darkness to a new light can be invoked. Ironically, far from the Kantian notion we have adopted a model of development for our country that is not only alien to our socio-cultural roots but has also made the country lose its own distinctive conceptualisation of the self.  Consequentially this has allowed our unique and independent paradigmatic stands to be crushed by the overarching influence of this emerging West in terms of cultural practices, material orientations and ideological commitments. This is what we call the ‘multiplications of wants’ – influenced by the western model of development, the priorities of the nation are targeted towards the growth of industrialization, the hegemonization of technology and the establishment of urbanization.
This unilinear , economy centric model of development has led to the growth of advanced forms of alienation, inequality and increasing individualism in society.

Not a very old incident from the eastern state of Odisha where a man named Majhi, carried his dead wife’s body for twelve kilometers after the hospital where she died failed to provide an ambulance to carry it back to the village reveals the tragic and utterly devastating impact of a developementalist agenda that does not take the common man into account. This is only a single incidence but every day there are hundreds of instances where the stark social inequality and lack of infrastructural initiative get reflected. These moments are clear indicators of the paradoxical relationship between the needs of society and the direction of development. Moreover such incidences indicate towards the ambitions of marketization which are to degrade human connectedness, destroy its uniqueness and cutoff all relationship with the soil. 

Invoking Gandhi

Amidst such a crisis I am exploring the traces of Gandhi, who had critically examined the violent ambitions of westernization and opposed market oriented development. He fought against the unconditional, unchallenged acceptance of the western model of development. He felt that this kind of development is unsuitable and devastating for the common people of India.
Gandhi was particularly inspired by Henry David Thoreau and John Ruskin to make the country self-reliant and to cultivate indigenous livelihoods and technologies needed for the development of all. It was the most viable and effective way to fight extreme poverty and backwardness that India was facing.  For Gandhi this idea of development emerged as an alternative and spiritual way of liberation that would lead India to total freedom both in the external world as well as in the inner realm. This project of nation building did not see the elites alone as the sole authors of modern India but believed in bringing together the subaltern: the oppressed castes and tribes, the poor peasantry, the minorities and building up a nation where they experienced collective prosperity. The Gandhian agenda was engaged with question of development at the very root/fundamental level concerning itself with the fulfillment of basic need for the people however his creative genius lay in the fact that he was able to reconcile this material concern with the higher concern and thus aimed to promote spiritual development and harmony with rejection of materialism and superficiality. For Gandhi the material and the spiritual; were intrinsically related and the development of one and the negligence of the other were not possible, they had to go hand in hand.
                                                           
Aspiring Middle Class and Consumerism

However, in present day India, we often realize how the public sector is slowly withdrawing itself from its role, disappearing as if purposefully to allow smooth privatization. From educational institutions to public hospitals we are reminded about the ailing bureaucracy in India. It would not be wrong to say that the Public sector is playing an important role in alienating the common people from functioning of the state. 

The complex structure of the bureaucracy with its gigantic machinery has distanced people from it. Moreover post liberalization the reluctance of the system to adapt and alter to meet the needs of the people and become more convenient for them has rapidly led to the downfall and degradation of many state run institutions. Problems such as corruption and nepotism have only added to the dilapidation of the system. Because of this dead weight of the bureaucracy and the lack of government initiatives to improve upon these, people are bound to move towards the private sectors. This means rapid liberalization and the gradual withdrawal of the state from the market and the economy at large. A characteristic of such a time is the proliferation of the urban-middle-class. It is a class that allows itself to be seduced by consumerism and emits the symbols of the West in all possible ways. This class has little to do with the concrete circumstances faced by the rest of India. They are prompt in condemning India for its lack of cultural sophistication and economic backwardness and poverty and they also feel a certain sense of shame and embarrassment to acknowledge that this is the country of their origin.
The West with its entrenched materiality and economic wealth has constituted the ultimate dream of the Indian middle class who see it as their ultimate liberation. It is indeed a hyper-materialistic society. Everything from education and health to relationships and ethics all are categories or turned into commodities transacted in the market.
This magical charm has successfully grasped both the state and masses who are increasingly convinced that the path to emancipation must go through ruthless development and imitation of the western capitalist mode of production. In fact, it is not just the urban-middle class that has lost its power of critical consciousness but even the state has not been spared. Projects like “Make In India” reiterate the state’s over dependence on MNCs, the World Bank, IMF. Indeed we have lost our own sense of agency , allowing gradually but consistently all indigenous economic methods to be ruined and crushed under the wheels of neoliberalism.
It is the greatest paradox of our times that India has not retained her distinctive voice and independent identity, it been completely taken over by the gigantic, dominative and even oppressive neoliberal market ethics.

The Idea of Gandhian Swaraj

In times such as these one begins to ask oneself a penetrating question, a question which takes us deep down to the roots of our own civilization history. If we have fought political colonialism why have we remained mentally colonized, where have we lost our own sense of self-respect?  Perhaps, when Gandhi spoke of Swaraj he was referring to this journey that we have so conveniently forgotten to undertake, but this is a journey without which, all journeys remain incomplete. There is indeed a colonizer, an oppressor within each one of us who does not allow us to move from darkness to light, from ignorance to knowledge. This oppressor likes to keep us ever dependent, lethargic and without a mind of our own. It is this enemy that he said we must fight against and win over when he talked about the significance of ruling over oneself (swaraj) before one thought of ruling the ‘other’. Today, our lack of grounded, socially embedded and people centric models of economic enterprise are all indicators of how hollow our notions of growth and progress are. We may call ourselves free but ironically we are still colonized by the logic of a singular modernity. Let us understand that there is not one but there are many modernities, let us for once have the strength of mind and heart to define it in our own indigenous way. Only then can we free ourselves from this golden cage which has never allowed us to experience the infinite sky!

Vikash Sharma is Founding Editor of The New Leam.

 

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

The Latest

How the West Discovered the Buddha

The article looks at how Buddhism as a way of life has gained currency in the West and the appeal it holds for its people.
- Advertisement -

US schools are not racially integrated, despite decades of effort

Are American schools really tolerant of the diversity in its cultural fabric or does racism continue to divide and disrupt practices of quality?

Philosophical Songs of Hindi Cinema

The article walks us through some of the popular songs from Indian cinema where the lyrics convey deep and profound messages

Birth Anniversary Special/ In-depth Review: J. Krishnamurti: A Life of Compassion beyond Boundaries

Here is a reflection on the delightful and informative read by historian Roshen Dalal delving into the life and ideas of the world teacher J. Krishnamurti.

J. Krishnamurti’s Birth Anniversary Special/ The New Leam in Conversation with Dr. Shailesh Shirali

In an insightful conversation with The New Leam. Dr. Shailesh Shirali shares glimpses of his own engagement with the ideas of J.Krishnamurti and the philosophy behind the Sahyadri School.

Jiddu Krishnamurti Birth Anniversary Special /The Violent Mind

As a wanderer, Jiddu Krishnamurti sought to decondition our minds. And in the age of violence, his reflections and revelations have acquired great relevance. Here is an excerpt from the lecture he delivered at the Benares Hindu University in 1969.

Related Stories

Gandhi, Education and Rural Reconstruction: An Abandoned Dream

Gandhi's vision of education is deeply intertwined with the idea of rural reconstruction, here is an article looking at this important issue.

Our Troubled World Can Learn Much From the Life and Message of Gandhi

The contributions of Mahatma Gandhi (1869-1948) have been regarded very highly by several of his contemporaries and those who followed. Albert Einstein said, “...

How Gandhi Failed to Search for ‘God’ in Benaras

I arrived Benaras in the morning. I had decided to put up with a panda. Numerous Brahmans surrounded me, as soon as I got out...

Mahatma Gandhi: The Spiritual Environmentalist

Mahatma Gandhi is perhaps one of those thinkers and visionaries whose contributions and articulations on themes as varied and diverse as politics, law and...

Che Lives

Remembering Che Guevara on his 93rd birth anniversary - the most romanticized revolutionary icon of the world.

How the West Discovered the Buddha

The article looks at how Buddhism as a way of life has gained currency in the West and the appeal it holds for its people.

US schools are not racially integrated, despite decades of effort

Are American schools really tolerant of the diversity in its cultural fabric or does racism continue to divide and disrupt practices of quality?

Philosophical Songs of Hindi Cinema

The article walks us through some of the popular songs from Indian cinema where the lyrics convey deep and profound messages

Jiddu Krishnamurti Birth Anniversary Special /The Violent Mind

As a wanderer, Jiddu Krishnamurti sought to decondition our minds. And in the age of violence, his reflections and revelations have acquired great relevance. Here is an excerpt from the lecture he delivered at the Benares Hindu University in 1969.

Does Cinema Hold the Potential of Contributing to a Better World?

Cinema is a very powerful medium which has been most commonly used to entertain people and to make money. However there is a higher...