Friday, April 23, 2021
More

    What Bihar Requires to Spend on Elementary School Education?

    Low funding in education has costed Bihar a lot and unless it prioritises school education and its democratisation under the RTE, it is bound to remain educationally deprived.

    RJD announced in its election manifesto that it would spend 22% of its budget on education. Nitish Kumar in his first term as the chief minister of the state had a clear focus on school education but did not carry this ahead in his subsequent terms. Without entering a blame game it is important to fathom what is required. This is not a marginal increase in budget allocation. In a recent national study, we inquired as to what the various states of the country  including Bihar, need to spend on the education sector in order to fulfil the promise of the RTE Act? (Bose, Ghosh & Sardana: RTE and the Resource Requirements https://www.eklavya.in/pdfs/Books/RTE_and_the_Resource_Requirements.pdf  )

    Based on school wise data collected by UDISE for the year 15-16, we could estimate that Bihar requires 45% more teachers at the primary level, 37% more at the upper primary level when compared to the norms prescribed under RTE. At the same time if we look at physical infrastructure we find that 10% of the schools have no building, where 11 lakh children study. Most other schools require additional classrooms. The average strength for primary school was 167 and for middle school this was 466. Schools are overcrowded. 

    A middle school teacher once commented that if all children come to school there would be just no space anywhere for them to sit! 75% additional classrooms are required compared to what is available. These deficits in the system has been pushing out poorer children and denying them their fundamental right to education. For those who can afford it, they all end up being enrolled in the parallel school-like coaching classes. 

    What are the constraints for expansion of school supply that have not really been addressed? Given acute land shortage since every inch is cultivated, the alternative is to construct properly two to three storied buildings. At the same there is also a need to create a social atmosphere where local bodies can negotiate & find some land for the village school. This is where political energy could be creative since this is an exercise in fraternity building among all communities. Similarly teacher recruitment has been a vexed issue and local arrangements have only supported a distribution of caste patronage. It is better to work with transparent bureaucratic norms akin to civil service recruitment. The policy of drawing teacher recruits from the maha-dalit groups has been fruitful and should be expanded. 

    Where will the money come from? In our study for 2015-16, we found that Bihar spends 13.4 % of its revenue receipts on elementary education, whereas the requirement to fulfil the mandate of RTE is 40%. What would be required for recurring expenditure is around Rs 51345 crore per year while it actually spends only 25% of this. This range of shortfall calls for a special allocation for education from the Finance Commission. In our report we have specified 16 states that require funds from the Centre to fulfil the constitutional obligations under RTE. Their own resources would be inadequate. Special grants are even more important during a pandemic since revenues are very low. One should not allow this situation to increase the out of school component of children. This would be irreversible. 

    There’s a section of experts who would ask us not to focus on inputs. They would be wasted. Their argument is to impose conditions that only improve outcomes of the process and that this should determine supply of additional inputs. Providing incentives to improve outcomes is their suggestion. 

    However government schools are not autonomous independent units amenable to incentives. They respond or react to the system of school administration as a whole and much more to emanating political signals. 

    This incentive-management system for public school education is a sure formula to achieve a low level equilibrium and the creation of a vast parallel private schooling. As the present situation indicates such deprivation can continue for decades.  

    On the other hand, is the need for channelizing the energy of this mandate to reform the working of school administration. 

    We have seen turnarounds in some other states where the school administration has taken effective steps to change the morale and ambience of government schools along with inputs for infrastructure. Adequate financial allocation is an enabling and necessary condition, but not sufficient to bring out the desired outcomes. It has to be accompanied by social policy and an atmosphere for transformation. The historical legacy of deficits is deep. Look at this with the lens of expanding social justice. Then the path would be clear and eminently doable.

    Arvind Sardana is an educationist and the former Director of  Eklavya, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh.

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    The Latest

    How Effective is the Union Budget 2021-22 in Terms of its Offerings to Women and Children? 

    The article below examines the effectiveness of the Budget in terms of its offerings to the women and child sectors.
    - Advertisement -

    As India’s COVID crisis worsens, leaders play the blame game while the poor suffer once again

    The need of the hour is for the nation-state to show decisive leadership in not only controlling the surge of the virus, but also providing financial assistance to millions of urban poor and making arrangements for them such that they can survive the pandemic with dignity.

    Amazon ‘Tribes on the Edge’: Q&A with documentary filmmaker Céline Cousteau

    Tribes on the Edge is a documentary produced by CauseCentric Productions, it has been directed and co-written by Céline Cousteau.The documentary explores the themes of land threats, health crises, and human rights issues of indigenous peoples.

    Shiksha Swaraj COVID-19 Response

    The COVID-19 pandemic has erected unprecedented challenges before the education sector in India and has deeply impacted children's access to learning resources and opportunities. While children from...

    The Gandhian Concept of Swadeshi and Why its Strikes a Greater Chord Today

    The concept of swadeshi played an important role in the freedom movement in India in opposing colonial exploitation, but as was emphasized by Mahatma Gandhi even then, we should also look at this concept in terms of its continuing relevance even after the end of colonial rule.

    After early success, India’s daily COVID infections have surpassed the US and Brazil. Why?

    India is in the grip of a massive second wave of COVID-19 infections, and lately it has been surpassing even the United States and Brazil in terms of new daily infection, why are we losing the battle against COVID-19 again?

    Related Stories

    How Effective is the Union Budget 2021-22 in Terms of its Offerings to Women and Children? 

    The article below examines the effectiveness of the Budget in terms of its offerings to the women and child sectors.

    A Beacon of Hope – Summerhill

    Summerhill is a book about the celebrated English boarding school named Summerhill School and has been written by its headmaster A. S. Neill. It is through this book that the educationist introduced his ideas to the American public. Here is an engaging and exhaustive reflection on the book by acclaimed educationist Arvind Gupta.

    An Analysis of NCF 2005 From the Caste Perspective

    The NCF 2005 is a pan Indian educational policy but its impact on different sections of the population is diverse, the article analyses the policy from the perspective of Dalits.

    Bhagat Singh’s version of nationalism and what it may mean for Indian education

    As we commemorate Bhagat Singh's 90th death anniversary, here is a close look at the ideas and vision that the man stood for.

    In-depth Review: J. Krishnamurti: A Life of Compassion beyond Boundaries

    Here is a reflection on the delightful and informative read by historian Roshen Dalal delving into the life and ideas of the world teacher J. Krishnamurti.

    Wage Labourer Builds Library, Displays Miraculous Determination to Rebuild it After it is Set on Fire

    Syed Issaq's library containing thousands of books on different religions of the world was recently burnt down by a mob of miscreants, but he is determined to rebuild this site of hope despite the odds.

    A Beacon of Hope – Summerhill

    Summerhill is a book about the celebrated English boarding school named Summerhill School and has been written by its headmaster A. S. Neill. It is through this book that the educationist introduced his ideas to the American public. Here is an engaging and exhaustive reflection on the book by acclaimed educationist Arvind Gupta.

    An Analysis of NCF 2005 From the Caste Perspective

    The NCF 2005 is a pan Indian educational policy but its impact on different sections of the population is diverse, the article analyses the policy from the perspective of Dalits.

    Bhagat Singh’s version of nationalism and what it may mean for Indian education

    As we commemorate Bhagat Singh's 90th death anniversary, here is a close look at the ideas and vision that the man stood for.

    In-depth Review: J. Krishnamurti: A Life of Compassion beyond Boundaries

    Here is a reflection on the delightful and informative read by historian Roshen Dalal delving into the life and ideas of the world teacher J. Krishnamurti.